Showing posts with label Human Rights. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Human Rights. Show all posts

Thursday, September 24, 2009

Zone 1- Asia. Telescopic Analysis: Human Rights Situation in the Central Asian Republics. Week # 83, Dated 30th Aug- 5th Sept.

Human Rights situation in the Central Asian republics remains at the forefront of international Human Rights Watch and continues to project a negative facet of the former soviet republics. Last week’s reports too included headlines that depict the dismal situation in the region.

Kazakhstan- Human Rights Activist sentenced to four years for allegedly trumped up charges:
A court in Kazakhstan has sentenced a prominent Human Rights activist, Yevgeny Zhovtis, to four years in jail for man slaughter amidst allegations of politically trumped up charges. The accused struck and killed a pedestrian with his car, however initial tests showed no alcohol in Zhovtis's blood and technical experts concluded there was no way to avoid the collision. Additional forensics tests conducted by the Kazakh authorities later over ruled the initial results.
The nature of the trial has been widely criticized as politically motivated. The human rights situation in Kazakhstan has come under increasing scrutiny as the country is poised to take over the rotating chairmanship of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) in 2010. Earlier Zhovtis, when invited by the OSCE to analyze the countries readiness had expressed the view that Kazakhstan was yet to meet its human rights obligations.

Turkmenistan- Turkmen Banned From Foreign Private Education:
Turkmenistan has banned its citizens from attending foreign private universities, Human Rights Watch (HRW) stated, urging the isolated Central Asian state to reverse the move. Maria Lisitsyna of HRW was quoted as saying "these arbitrary travel restrictions are disturbing new proof of how repressive Turkmenistan's government is."
Turkmenistan became notorious for various restrictions and isolationist policies under late leader Saparmurat Niyazov who had run the country for 21 years as a personal fiefdom, banning gold teeth and renaming months in the year after his family. Though his successor has reversed some of his policies, but HRW claims with little genuine change.
According to the Turkmen Initiative of Human Rights, a Vienna-based NGO, Turkmen authorities are mostly concerned with non-state universities, such as American University in Central Asia (AUCA) with a large number of students receiving financial support from the US state department and other donors. The HRW has also criticized the west for engaging with the country because of its oil reserves.
Human Rights groups continue to rally against the national government while also pressurizing international bodies, hence far with little results.

Uzbekistan- State Sponsored Religious Persecution; followers’ of late Turkish Muslim theologian Said Nursi sentenced to prison terms:
The Uzbek authorities launched a huge clampdown on Muslims promoting Nursi's teachings in late 2008 and this year has already seen heavy sentences handed down on dozens of adherents. Two mass trials which ended in July have brought to 47 the number of followers of the late Turkish Muslim theologian Said Nursi, sentenced to prison terms totaling some 380 years under various articles of the Criminal Code in Uzbekistan in 2009.
Human Rights activists have reported brutal beatings of the detainees in pre trial detention. While two human rights groups noted that the cases of extremism against the accused were not proven and they were basically sentenced for practicing religion outside the framework of the traditional state propagated Islam.
Uzbekistan's Law on Freedom of Conscience and Religious Organizations, passed in May 1998, severely restricts the exercise of religious freedom, through regulations that are often arbitrarily applied. The Human Rights situation at present remains dismal.
----------------------------------

Discussion Questions:

· It seems that the Human Rights debate is not very public in the Central Asian Republics with most media and Human Rights Reports originating in foreign media. Does this depict a) a lack of political will in the region or b) is it simply a consequence of state oppression?

· To what extent do you think embedded international interests in the region complicate the situation and provide some semblance of immunity from international pressures?

· Is the parochial and paranoid state action a consequence of nascent political systems and weak institutions in the region?
________________________________________________________
Business and Politics in the Muslim World (BPM)refers to the project entitled, "Globalized Business and Politics: A View from the Muslim World.' This project has been undertaken and developed by the Gilani Research Foundation as a free resource and social discussion tool.

Monday, September 14, 2009

Microscopic Analysis- Malaysia- a Model State? Week # 83; Dated 29th Aug-4th Sept.


Malaysian Projection of a Moderate Muslim State- a complicated relationship between religion and politics:

Recently a relatively isolated event where a Malaysian woman was found guilty of drinking alcohol and sentenced to six strokes of the cane, made international headlines. Many at the domestic Islamist front fail to understand the disquieting international reaction. But in the wider context of international politics Malaysia is looking more and more like an isolated, parochial state, raising a dilemma for the state that aims at projecting it self as a moderate model Muslim nation.

Muslims account for nearly 60% of Malaysia's 27 million people and they are barred from consuming alcohol under Islamic laws. The problem, one analyst[1] notes is manifold: for one the ruling, handled by the Shariah court of Pahang now raises the question of whether the Federal government can intervene to save face internationally. Federal-state relations in legal matters will therefore be the crux of the legal side of the debate.

Adding to the confusion is the problematic and complicated relationship between religion and politics in the country, where the borderline between Islam and politics has grown increasingly blurred after three decades of ‘state-driven Islamisation’.

Yet another incident was the recent ban levied at a concert in Kuala Lumpur because it was being sponsored by an Irish Beer Company. Though the decision was later revoked in order to boost tourism, it projects a basic predicament for the state in Malaysia. As a nation economically banking on a boosting tourist industry, the situation is made all the more complicated.

The dilemma lies in the balancing act of projecting moderation while not offending the conservative Islamic community. Malaysia has long been trying to cultivate its image as a moderate model state able to act as a cultural bridge between the west and the Muslim world. Though Malaysia’s ruling UMNO party is trying its best to defend its own Islamic credentials in the face of the opposition Islamic party PAS. The Islamic party in turn is split in its conscience, between moderates who wish to push the democratization agenda and conservatives who wish to lay the foundations for more Islamisation.



Discussion Questions:

· Has the ‘state driven Islamisation’ in Malaysia irrevocably damaged the nation’s international image?

· Does the degree of influence from international elements depict an erosion of state sovereignty?

· In a predominantly Muslim nation, with established democratic institutions, is the goal to keep religion and politics separate too ambitious?


-----------------------


________________________________________________________
Business and Politics in the Muslim World (BPM)refers to the project entitled, "Globalized Business and Politics: A View from the Muslim World.' This project has been undertaken and developed by the Gilani Research Foundation as a free resource and social discussion tool.